Curling for Democracy

Posted February 8, 2006 By Dave Thomer

I make no bones about the fact that I have been looking forward to curling at this year’s Olympics since, oh, 2002. And you may recall that a few weeks ago I commented on Washington, D.C.’s lack of representation in Congress. Well, not since chocolate and peanut butter got together have I seen a more fortuitous combination than the D.C. Olympic Curling Team. The premise is, other U.S. territories that lack representation, like Puerto Rico, get to send their own teams to the Olympics. So why shouldn’t D.C.? The organizers decided to focus on curling because they figured that was their best shot. 🙂 Right now the site has an online petition urging the IOC to recognize a D.C. team for 2010, a blog, and some other basic info.

Bring on the curling! And bring on the democracy!

        

Two Poles of Deliberative Democracy

Posted February 7, 2006 By Dave Thomer

I wanted to start making these posts weeks ago, but got sidetracked. I’ve already tried to put a Deweyan notion of democracy into a nutshell here. I’d like to start talking about a vein of democratic theory that’s seen a lot of activity in the last couple of decades, deliberative democracy. Depending on how you view it, it can be a complement or an alternative to the Deweyan notion, but we’ll have time to talk about that later. For now I want to sketch a definition and present one of the key discussion points within the ranks of those who call themselves deliberative democrats. Read the remainder of this entry »

        

Pattie’s Pop Culture Obsessions

Posted January 29, 2006 By Pattie Gillett

I’ll admit, this topic of this post is ripped off from a similar blog at Bravotv.com (which is, in itself, one of my current obsessions). This list is a random collection of stuff I’m fascinated with these days. As Dave will attest, when something fascinates me, the people around me have no other choice than to become fascinated with it as well…this now includes you guys, sorry!

Bravo’s Project Runway (Season 2) – I know very little about fashion, less about design, and my sewing skills are so low they might as well be rated by negative numbers. Still, this show featuring supermodels, wannabe superstar designers, and arcane fashion jargon has replaced Law and Order as my essential Wednesday night viewing. (What’s the difference, I can just catch the L&O shows I miss, or ones that are eeerily similar to them, later, on any of twenty cable channels.) I’m not going to be one of these people who swears they don’t watch any other reality TV because I have been known to sit through episodes of Survivor, The Amazing Race, and The Real World. Reality TV can be fun, if done well. But even when it’s done poorly, it’s hard to turn it off!

What sets Project Runway apart for me is at the end of the day, the competition is (mostly) about talent and creativity. Yes, there’s some drama, yes, there are male and female divas-aplenty but it’s still fun to watch. One of the things I like best is that there’s very little attempt to distinguish the designer from their design. Everyone is very frank about how much of themselves they put in their work. Having worked in business for close to ten years and been told repeatedly “it’s not personal, it’s just business� it’s refreshing to see that there is a flipside out there somewhere, even if it’s not my field. My take has always been that if you did it, and worked hard on it, it is personal, no matter what it is. Call me crazy, but the more I think the more you separate yourself from what you do, the less successful and rewarding that work is. Fine, maybe I am crazy.

The Olympics – They opening ceremonies are just days away (as I write this) and you can feel the anticipation in the Gillett-Thomer household. We are Olympic junkies, especially for the Winter Games. We’re also geeks but you knew that already. In the summer games, you can see quite clearly how most of the sports connect to the human experience: swimming, running, even archery. In the winter games, the connection is not always so clear. I mean, I doubt the Scottish highlanders invented curling as a means of survival. And figure skating? Unless someone comes forth with irrefutable proof that triple salchows were the only way for our ancestors to escape hungry Alpine bears, I’m standing by my assessment that this sport is as much about sex appeal as it is about athleticism. Dave will no doubt protest me calling figure skating a sport but hey, it wouldn’t be an Olympic year if he didn’t.

Many of the winter games seem to have been created out of boredom than real need for human survival, which is what makes them so darn entertaining. And for those of us at home, it is just that, entertainment. Yes the Olympics themselves are about athleticism, but they are as much about pageantry, hence the multi-million dollar opening and closing ceremonies. They’re also about making money, hence the billion dollar sponsorship deals. Still, I love my figure skating (and speed skating, and ski-jump) and Dave loves his curling. I’ll be watching as much of the 16-day extravaganza as I can. Mostly to see if any Alpine bears show up.

Enron, The Smartest Guys in the Room – Being a business grad student and resident of planet Earth, I was certainly aware of the accounting scandal that this documentary, and the book it was based on, chronicled. But, as with many things following the birth if my daughter, the details were a little fuzzy. I have heard that this documentary was good so I decided to pop it in my DVD player one quiet afternoon. The afternoon didn’t stay quiet for very long because I was soon shouting at my TV. To me, what happened here is truly human nature at its worst. Between what I always knew about Enron’s execs, and evidence brought forth in this documentary, I have to wonder how Skilling, Lay and company plan to survive their upcoming trials. I’m not speaking metaphorically, either. They must live in constant fear that some devastated ex-Enron employee or family member is simply going to exact their own form of justice one way or another. To quote a dear friend of mine, who is often mortified at the sheer callousness of human beings, “one Hell cannot possibly be big enough� to house people who do things like this.

But back to the documentary, it’s the rare non-fiction film work that can create kind of drama about a story you more or less already know. Armed with music, striking imagery, tasteful re-enactments, and some stunning pieces of evidence, the creators did just that.
Obviously, I have my own opinions about the guilt and innocence of the principals in this case; it’s almost impossible not to. However, there are those, even among the filmmakers, who do see a difference between criminal culpability and moral culpability. Is there one? Rent or buy this DVD and decide for yourself.

Sherlock Holmes – Santa was kind to me this year and brought me The Complete Sherlock Holmes in a single collected edition. I’ve decided, after re-reading the first few Holmes tales, that I will try to reread most of the books that I really enjoyed when I was in my teens and early twenties now, as I creep ever nearer to the big 3-0. When I first read Doyle, I was blown away by the details of each mystery and focused almost entirely on those aspects. I missed a great deal of Doyle’s character development, wit and detail the first time around, perhaps because I was too impatient, too naïve, or too preoccupied with term papers the first time around. Now, I truly am reading it for fun. Of course, now I need to fit in my leisure reading around finger painting and episodes of Dora the Explorer but you see my point.
In the ensuing years, I’ve become familiar with several Hollywood versions of Holmes, some brilliant (Jeremy Brett), some questionable (Rupert Everett), but none really equals picking p the books and reading them, or rather, re-reading them, for myself.

Home Improvements – Replacement windows, repainting, new doors, new rugs, refinishing the floors, retiling…the homeowners’ work is never done. No, really, it’s NEVER done. One of the joys of owning a home is that you get to choose the renovations and improvements that you make. One of the problems of home-ownership is that you have to pay for the renovations and improvements that you make. Every once and while, though, Uncle Sam cuts you a break on the costs of your home renovations, which is probably how most ever happen at all. Let’s face it, a large percentage of homeowners are probably as motivated by this stuff as I am. Which is why I tend to want to make improvements in large bursts of activity; these bursts are then followed by long periods of inactivity during which I watch television and read mystery books while the house creaks beneath me.

        

Capital Concerns

Posted January 27, 2006 By Dave Thomer

In my American Thinkers class we were discussing the Declaration of Independence, as I was preparing my lecture notes I was struck by a thought: Don’t the citizens of Washington, D.C. have cause for rebelling against the government? The Constitution gives Congress absolute final power over the District of Columbia, yet D.C. has no voting representation in either house. How is this the kind of thing that we tolerate in this day and age? And why did it take me so long to get riled up about it?

        

Like They Knew I Was Coming

Posted January 23, 2006 By Dave Thomer

I know there are some folks who were irked when VH1 Classic expanded its playlist to include songs from the early 90s. (I think their rule went from “must be from the 80s or earlier” to “must be at least ten years old.”) But me, I don’t mind at all. While trying to get Alex to sleep I checked out tonight’s “The Alternative” block, and within an hour they played They Might Be Giants’ “Birdhouse in Your Soul,” R.E.M.’s “Feeling Gravitys Pull,” Matthew Sweet’s “Sick of Myself” and Dada’s “Dizz Knee Land.” That would’ve been a good hour’s listening back in the heyday of WDRE (the modern rock station I listened to in high school).

And that reminds me, I have to see if I can get tickets to Dada’s show in Philly next month . . .

        

Blogging Dewey: Art and Aesthetics

Posted January 20, 2006 By Dave Thomer

Couple of Dewey citations with an artistic theme in the blogosphere this week:

Alex Starace at Professor Yeti mentions Art as Experience as part of a discussion of how art can communication vital emotional and contextual information that can’t be boiled down to mere facts. It’s a very interesting piece, although I kinda wish there was some mention of Dewey’s parallel argument in Experience and Nature that science and thinking is, itself, a kind of art, although in that case Dewey was defining art much more broadly.

Meanwhile, Rob Comber at Controlled by Remote uses one of my favorite passages from Art as Experience to talk about the different user experiences provided by different models of web site. A brief but interesting post.

        

Blogging Dewey: Education Talk

Posted January 19, 2006 By Dave Thomer

With the start of a new academic semester, it seems a lot of education students are reading, talking, and blogging about Dewey. Here’s a sampling of some comments:

  • Senorita Teacher wonders whether the Deweyan idea of “starting where the child is” can be effective at higher grade levels.
  • Shannon at My Life Becoming a Teacher reflects on Dewey’s thoughts on education as social and calls Dewey’s words empowering.
  • DancnTeach responds to a line from “Pedagogic Creed:”

    I believe that education, therfore, is a process of living and not a preparation for future living.

  • Kristin at Cute as a Button wonders if Dewey’s ideas are still relevant today, and whether implementing them is in any way realistic.
  • Tirade25 at Tirade Parade reflects on her unpleasant experience within an education program, where she feels that Deweyan ideology replaced the actual teaching of techniques and skills. Ironically enough, she notes in the comments, a Deweyan learn-by-doing approach was not actually implemented in these programs. (I admit I have struggled myself from time to time with the notion of lecturing on Dewey. It seems somehow counterproductive, and yet at the moment that’s the system we work with.)

I also came across two posts that conflate Dewey with the idea of completely unstructured or child-dominated education. One cites the possibility of a negative progressive-ed influence on home schooling. This may or may not be a valid critique of certain forms of progressive-ed in home schooling, but as I’ve said before, Dewey’s concept of education was not devoid of structure. The other post , and another blames the Laboratory School at Chicago for ushering in an age of lower literacy. I just have a hard time reconciling that last claim with Dewey’s idea that art and literature were so important to education. It’s not the first time I’ve seen the charge though, so I think I’m going to need to hunt down some reliable statistics on literacy in Western societies.

        

What’s Old Is New Again. Sorta.

Posted January 18, 2006 By Dave Thomer

I’ve begun pulling essays from the original HTML version of the site and both incarnations of the forums and putting them into WordPress with timestamps that reflect their original dating. When I’m done this should make it far less cumbersome to explore the content we’ve accumulated over the last five years. When I’m done, I’ll remove the link to the HTML archive from the sidebar. I’ll probably keep the link to the phpbb forum active, though, since there is good stuff there that’s not easily translatable to the blog format. (Well, I could just turn each thread into its own post. But that is so low on my priority list that it’s underground.)

Right now I’ve brought the philosophy section up to date. Public policy will be next up.

There should be some actual new posts coming as well tonight or tomorrow.

        

The Truthiness Hurts

Posted January 13, 2006 By Dave Thomer

Stephen Colbert may well be my new journalistic hero. His “The Word” segment on The Colbert Report is almost always a funny and intelligent commentary on current affairs, never more so than on his first episode where he coined the word “truthiness” – or at least a new meaning for it. The American Dialect Society apparently agreed, and named truthiness their word of the year for 2005. Well, when the Associated Press ran a story on the decision, they neglected to mention Colbert. So he took a shot at them on last night’s episode, and in this AP article. The guy stays in character to skewer the AP, the war on Iraq, and the linguistic expert that the AP quoted in their first article. Great stuff.

        

Blogosphere Brainstorming

Posted January 12, 2006 By Dave Thomer

While I try to get myself sufficiently up to speed to make some longer posts here, let me link to a couple of blogs that are brainstorming some policy ideas for Philadelphia and Pennsylvania where I’ve tried to chip in to the conversation:

Young Philly Politics has a discussion of how a major investment in mass transit expansion could spur economic activity. Having spent five years in New York, I’m all for beefing up public transit in this town.

Joe Hoeffel proposes that initiative, referendum, and recall should be implemented in Pennsylvania. I am decidedly less enthusiastic about the idea.