This Is Not News Forums - Edit this post

This is an archived forum only.
The discussion continues at the Not News Forums.

Forum: Comics
Topic: Rise of The Red Star (December 2000)

Only forum leaders (Guardian of Peace and Justice in the Galaxy, True Believer) or the person that posted this message may edit or delete this message. Only registered users may edit/delete posts!
Delete? To delete this post, check this box.
Your UserName:
Your Password:	Forget your password?
Message to Edit: HTML is OFF UBB Code is OFF Smilies Legend	Originally posted by Brian Thomer on 01-03-2001 02:36 PM Why is it I always gotta be the bad cop around here, and this time I'm playing against 3 good cops? Shit. Right off the bat I am gonna say that The Red Star is a great read, I won't question that. My problem lies within the interview on this site. I think Christian comes off as a very arrogant self righteous ummmm... individual. Having only been successful in the comics industry for a very short period of time I think it's a little presumptuous for him to bash a vast majority of the industry and to think that he has the cure within his mere three issue so far published series. Even though eventually he may be correct that their innovative style and storytelling may have a great impact on the industry and cause some sort of turnaround, but at this point it's just way too early to start proclaiming it as such. The same thing about his political stance, he goes on and on about his beliefs and bashes anyone else that does or thinks differently. And quite frankly that's not something I'm looking for when reading a comic creator interview, now granted this is probably partly in fault in Dave's questions, but I still don't think Christian needs to shove his beliefs so harshly down our throats. I understand that this book has strong political ties and that a vast amount of research went into it, but I just don't see that sort of thing as necessary. Instead of trying to force feed it to us why don't you tell us about how you came across those beliefs and tell us about the six years spent researching the material. I'd be much more receptive to that. You catch more flies with honey or however that saying goes. Quite honestly I haven't seen such a huge political message in this book not any more than other books, maybe that's my own ignorance. It very well could be there and I'm just missing it. Maybe that bar Pattie spoke of is above my reach. Or maybe I just don't see it as big of an issue that everyone else is making it into. I know when I'm in over my head but it appears more to be the presumptions and arrogance of the creative team. And all the blame can't be placed on them as I said. Dave did ask the questions that set up those answers and I can see Dave's desire to try to stay away from the "same old" comic book interview, but I think more of an integration of the "same old" interview and the one Dave conducted is necessary, that way people unfamiliar with the subject (such as myself) and those very familiar with it (such as everyone else on this thread) are both satisified. But Christian definitely gains my respect for signing onto these boards and posting.
	Disable Smilies in This Post.
*If HTML and/or UBB Code are enabled, this means you can use HTML and/or UBB Code in your message.

Contact Us | This Is Not News Home | Privacy Statement

All message board posts are copyright their respective posters.

Ultimate Bulletin Board Version 5.47a